On the planet Helotrix a Federation officer, Colonel Quute, interrogates a guerilla fighter. As interrogations go it’s nice and friendly and the rebel seems extremely compliant. Quute gets all that he needs out of the man and then gives him a drink. He then releases him. After the prisoner’s gone Quute says it’s too easy.
The prisoner, Igin, heads back into the marshlands surrounding the city to connect with the guerrilla army of Major Hunda. He’s spotted by scouts who report to Hunda who tells them to signal Igin to stay where he is and not approach any closer until they’re sure he hadn’t been followed.
It’s a precaution that saves all their lives because the drink contained a tracker and now, after Igin’s signal stays still for some time, Quute assumes he’s contacted Hunda and Federation artillery blasts the area.
On Scorpio Orac reports that Helotrix is now back in Federation hands. The crew are surprised at this because the Helots are renowned fighters and it took the Federation a huge amount of effort to suppress them last time, now they seem to have been retaken very easily and they’re not the first, a series of former colonies have been retaken by the Federation without effort and Avon wants to know why.
Tarrant and Dayna will teleport down to find out more, they’ll discover details of the Federation’s new pacification program, and they’ll also bump into an old ‘friend’.
That Traitor somewhat falls short of being a classic is down, I suspect, to a simple lack of budget. There is a lot going on in this episode and some plot threads are explored better than others, with a slightly longer run time to breathe this could have been a classic, as it stands some elements feel rushed, and the final battle is awful. I recall someone once telling me that it was supposed to take place in some grand bustling concourse, that could have been great. Everyone brawling on an obviously fake set works less well.
There is a lot to like about Traitor however, not least the introduction of Commissioner Sleer, who we don’t see for a long time, and whose gender is explicitly not mentioned for some reason. We then have someone killing high ranking Federation officials and destroying paintings of Servalan, and when we finally hear Sleer’s voice, it does sound a little like Jacqui, but Servalan’s dead, isn’t she?
As always it’s hard to consider this in context. Did people guess Servalan was back very quickly, or were there genuine gasps of shock when she appeared at the end? Who can say. I certainly don’t remember if I was surprised back in 1981. I have to say that I’m not sure Jacqui has ever looked sexier, I’m almost envious of Leitz…what a way to go!
It is a trifle preposterous that so few people know what the President and Supreme Commander of the Terran Federation looked like of course, and I’m sure there’s an argument to say that Servalan should have stayed dead, but when you have a villain as glorious as her, it would have been a shame if she hadn’t returned, the only annoyance (spoiler!) is that she won’t feature in the series finale.
The Pacification Program is a wonderful conceit, giving a weakened Federation quite a shot in the arm, and forcing our heroes to take a more proactive interest in galactic affairs than they’d had in Series C where any meddling with Servalan’s plans tended to be happy coincidence rather than anything planned. That pylene-50 was originally designed for a more benign purpose is an interesting wrinkle, foreshadowing the invention of Viagra which was designed to treat angina and ended up becoming more famous for a very different use!
If pylene-50 is great then it’s creator Forbus is a little undercooked, and just why does Servalan kill him at the end? Who’s going to make her drug now?
The guest cast are good, although there’s a lot of white males around, would have been nice to see a token female resistance fighter, and given Robert Holmes makes a big deal of lampshading Dayna’s ethnicity it’s a shame we don’t see many people who look like her. In particular Malcolm Stoddard as Leitz and Nick Brimble as the General are a little interchangeable at first. It’s hard to mistake Christopher Neame for anyone else of course, even before the eye patch, and I love his scenes, playing chess while he launches artillery (chess of course being something Holmes put in practically every script) and his conversations with the General over (space) wine, and they have a nice difference of opinions. The Colonel is happy to stay behind the lines and pick his enemy off with brainwashing and long range missiles, while the General is a hands-on kind of man and seems to miss the hand to hand nature of combat.
Leitz is an interesting character, playing both ends against the middle, though he goes from being a Machiavellian character to a complete idiot in his final moments of course.
There are some nice exterior shots of Binnegar Heath sandpits, though in some respects this only highlights how ropey the studio bits are.
It’s also nice to see shadows of colonialism here, with the Federation recruiting locals (albeit unwillingly) to do their fighting for them, which of course means that even as the rebels win their skirmish, in some ways they also lose because they’re killing their own people. We also have Practor, the new planetary governor who, much like Ro in Horizon, is a local and who, unlike those Helot soldiers, is a willing Federation tool. The conversations between the general and the colonel feed into this also, discussing the next far flung destination they’re going to pacify, and talking about the locals the way one might imagine colonial officers discussing native tribesmen in the 19th Century.
This is mainly a Tarrant/Dayna story and as usual they work well together. Tarrant is a trifle more heroic and less of a dick than usual, even after Avon warns him not to get involved, even if they’re executing the population. Dayna and Tarrant of course completely ignore this order.
The others don’t get much to do. Soolin in particular is shortchanged. Given this is her first full episode as a member of the crew it you’d think it would be good for her to get involved—in fact imagine how cool if Soolin and Dayna had been the ones to teleport down?
Vila mainly complains that they should leave Tarrant and Dayna to their fate, though he does get a nice moment when he tells Avon Blake would be proud of him.
“Yes,” replies Avon. “But then he never was very bright.” This is probably the Avon highlight of the episode, though he has another great moment where it appears he’s glad Servalan is still alive, and he is, but only because he wants to kill her himself.
Aside from this it’s amusing that Orac’s laziness drops them in it, and thankfully Forbus provided them with an antidote to Pylene-50. All in all, not a bad days work for the heroes and a solid episode even if it isn’t a classic.
Next time, Dr Who?